LinkedIn co-founder; Impromptu author
Representative of Reid's essay-writing threads — drafting with Claude as a sparring partner, where the model pushes back on weak arguments before they reach an editor.
“The first reader used to be my editor. Now the first reader is the model — and the model asks better questions.”
How to replicate
- 1.Draft the essay yourself — do not let the model write the first pass.
- 2.Paste the draft to Claude and instruct it to steelman the opposing view.
Prompt template
I wrote this essay: <paste>. Do not rewrite it. Instead: (1) steelman the strongest counter-argument in 2 paragraphs. (2) Mark the 3 weakest claims and say what evidence would convince a skeptic. (3) Flag any sentence that reads as received wisdom. Be direct. Don't compliment — critique.
Pitfall
Letting the model rewrite instead of critique. Once it rewrites, the voice is gone. Lock it to 'critique only' and keep the keyboard.
What you'll learn
- •How to use an LLM as a hostile first reader
- •Why critique prompts beat rewrite prompts for voice preservation
- •How to surface weak arguments before they reach an audience
- •When to ignore the model's critique
